Broadway By the Bay and its staff and performers have garnered an impressive list of awards and recognition over the years. One of the most prestigious forms of acknowledgement are the awards presented annually by the San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle. Nominations are made in January and the winners are announced in late March of each year. Below is a listing of recipients in years past. We also congratulate the many other actors and staff who have been nominated over the years.

BBBay 2006 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Entire Production - Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
* Tiffany Marie-Austin - Best Supporting in a Musical (female) for Miss Saigon
* David Sattler - Best Supporting in a Musical (male) for Miss Saigon
* Paul Araquistain - Best Supporting in a Musical (male) for Miss Saigon
* Alex Perez - Best Director for Miss Saigon
* Mark Hanson - Best Musical Director for Miss Saigon
* Michael Ramsaur - Best Lighting Design for Miss Saigon
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for Seven Brides for Seven Brothers
* Robin Tribuzi - Best Choreography for Miss Saigon

BBBay 2005 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for Cabaret
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for Funny Girl

BBBay 2004 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Melissa Wolfklain - Best Leading in a Musical (female) for Singin' In the Rain
* Paige Cook Perez- Best Supporting in a Musical (female) for Singin' In the Rain
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for Singin' In the Rain
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for West Side Story

BBBay 2002 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Susan Himes Powers - Best Leading in a Musical (female) for Camelot
* Ann Meyers - Best Supporting in a Musical (female) for Anything Goes
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for Anything Goes
* Best Overall Production (Musical) - Anything Goes

BBBay 2001 Critics' Circle Award Winners|
* Carolyn Steuck - Best Supporting in a Musical (female) for Damn Yankees
* Larry Diskin - Best Supporting in a Musical (male) for Damn Yankees
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for Damn Yankees
* Rick Reynolds - Best Musical Direction - Jesus Christ Superstar
* Susan Himes Powers - Best Principal Performance (female) for The Music Man

BBBay 2000 Critics' Circle Award Winner
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for A Chorus Line

PCLO 1999 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Simon Relph - Best Supporting Actor in a Musical (male) for Phantom
* Sid Cato - Best Actor in a Musical (male) for 42nd Street
* Berle Davis - Best Choreography for 42nd Street
* Michael Ramsaur - Best Lighting in a Musical for Phantom
* Phantom - Best Entire Musical

PCLO 1998 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Candy Cotton Farbstein - Best Supporting Actor in a Musical (female) for Dolly!
* Andy Ragone - Best Actor in a Musical (male) for Joseph
* Michael Ramsaur - Best Lighting in a Musical for Joseph
* Sharon McNight - Best Actor in a Musical (female) for Dolly!

PCLO 1997 Critics' Circle Award Winners
* Brooke Knight (Outstanding Director) for Guys and Dolls
* Berle Davis (Outstanding Choreographer)
* Darlene Popovic (Outstanding Principal Performance (female)) for Guys and Dolls
* PCLO (Outstanding Overall Musical Production Award) for Guys and Dolls
* Joseph Fincher (Outstanding Supporting Performance, (male)).